Now, a third movie is closer than ever to actually happening, as Bledel (currently starring on Hulu's "The Handmaid's Tale") told Jimmy Fallon on Thursday's "The Tonight Show."
"We just pitched a third movie," she revealed. "I hope it comes together. It would be so great."
The time seems right for a revival, a decade after the second film. And revivals are big these days; Bledel herself was in the Netflix's "Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life" follow-up.
Lively also recently added fuel to the fire at CinemaCon, saying, "I think it could really happen."
"I think that people who love the movie want to see it. So, I mean, fans have gotten bigger movies made," she added. Then, referencing husband Ryan Reynolds' biggest hit, "'Deadpool' is all thanks to the fans. So I'm saying we'll do it."